Friday, January 9, 2009

BCS Championship and My FInal Poll

First of all, kudos to cnnsi.com for having the headline "BCS Champions" (as pointed out to me by valuable Ramblings reader Jack Skaggs) instead of "National Champions", because this year we aren't even close to having a national champion.  All we are left with is a muddled mess of very good teams with imperfect resumes - each of Florida, Texas, Utah and USC can rightly argue that they were the best team in the country...but the glittery football is heading back to Gainesville (motto: At least we're not Waco).

You can't tell me that after the national title game, each of Utah, USC and UT didn't think they could have beaten each of the 2 teams playing in the championship.  Neither Florida nor Oklahoma played badly, but neither put on a show that made anyone think "Wow, that is the best team in the country."  Thus, we now have a host of teams claiming that they are the best team in the country..and how can anyone tell them they aren't.

Until we have a playoff, here are my top 25 teams:

25. Rice (10-3) - I think we beat Georgia Tech head to head.  Thus, we get in.

24. Michigan St. (9-4) - Gave Georgia a tough game in the bowl.  Solid, if unspectacular team.

23.  BYU (10-3) - Really surprised they lost to Arizona.  Another program building season though out in Provo.

22. Florida St. (9-4) - Seminoles are rising once again.  Odds are their GPAs are not.

21. West Virginia (9-4) - Congrats to Pat White after becoming the only QB to start and win 4 bowl games.  Great, great college player.

20. Iowa (9-4) - Played so well down the stretch AND kept Penn St. out of the national title game.  An appreciative nation thanks you Hawkeyes.

19. Cincinnati (11-3) - You win the Big East? Whoop.  You got manhandled by a Virginia Tech team that hadn't looked that good all year.  Program on the rise though.

18. Oregon St. (9-4) - Despite winning the ugliest bowl game ever (3-0) I'm still impressed they could get a W in spite of the absence of top players.  Watch them in 2009.

17. Missouri (10-4) - Just never got it going this year.  A VERY disappointing season when you see what they were hoping to accomplish in 2008.  

16. Virginia Tech (10-4) - After a below average season by this program's standards, pulled out some serious whoop-ass on Cincinnati.  Just a great college football program year in and year out.

15. Oklahoma St. (9-4) - If only they had a defense.

14. Texas Tech (11-3) - Apparently thought the season was over after beating Oklahoma St. on 11/8, because they were terrible in the last 3 games they played.

13. Georgia (10-3) - Never lived up to preseason billing, but a good season nonetheless.  Lot of weapons are going to be lost to the draft.

12. Mississippi (9-4) - The only team to beat Florida lost their 4 games by a combined 19 points.  THE team on the rise in the SEC. Hey Hog fans, still think Houston Nutt can't coach?

11. Ohio St. (10-3) - Played a great Fiesta Bowl game despite Pryor not being able to throw the ball more than 10 yards at a time.  Tell the band to lay off playing the fight song though, k?

10. Oregon (10-3) - Just rolling at the end of the year!  Couldn't move them past Boise St. though, since Boise St. beat them AT Oregon during the year.

9. Boise St. (12-1) - Played TCU to a near draw...underrated team and underrated program.  Think a 12-0 regular season team wouldn't be interested in a playoff?

8. Penn St. (11-2) - If only they had gotten the memo that the Rose Bowl was two halves and not just one...might have set their wakeup call earlier.

7. TCU (11-2) - Beat a tough Boise St. team in the bowl after a great regular season.  Most underrated program in the country.

6. Alabama (12-2) - Only team in the top 10 to finish the season with a losing streak.  Manhandled by Utah which makes me smile, if only because Nick Saban is one of the least engaging and gregarious people in the country.

5. Oklahoma (12-2) - 45-35.  24-14.  Suck it OU.

4. USC (12-1) - Seriously, how did they ever lose to Oregon St.?  Great ballclub.

3. Texas (12-1) - Oh Blake Gideon....so close.

2. Florida (12-1) - Great team with an even greater coach.  

1. Utah (13-0) - Beat everyone in front of them, including 4 ranked teams. Dominated Alabama in the sugar bowl.  Do I think they are the best team? No. They are definitely top 5 though, and if their name was "Florida" or "Texas" they are in the title game.  Hats off to the Utes.

No comments: